NYC’s Newest Pizza Hits Include Cheesy Focaccia and Buzzetti

Despite the current availability of 20 or so distinct types of pizza in the city, a new addition is always welcome. Such an event occurred recently with the opening of Coco Pazzeria on Spring Street just west of Soho. This place serves not only the requisite pizzas and sandwiches, but also intriguing, cheese-filled focaccia and a doughy item called buzzetti, which I’ve never encountered before. Indeed, the focaccia robiola, in particular, totally overshadows the pizzas that are the ostensible purpose of the place.

If the name Coco Pazzeria sounds familiar, the restaurant’s predecessor was Coco Pazza, an Upper East Side celebrity magnet in the ’90s. Founded by Pino Luongo, it eventually migrated downtown to Soho, where it never enjoyed quite the same popularity, but is still in business today.

A gray facade with a banner with the name of the restaurant across the front.

Soho West has a new pizzeria.

But now Luongo, along with pizzaiolo Ciro Verde, has opened a dough-based restaurant a few blocks west. Coco Pazzeria occupies the old Giorgione space near the Ear Inn, in a riverside neighborhood known for its obscurity and quietude — though several high-rise condos are raucously under construction not far away. (It’s also worth noting that nearly two decades ago, Via Carota partner Jody Williams made the wood-burning oven installed there famous with her thin-crust artisanal pizzas.)

Among the Neapolitan pizzas and hero sandwiches that fill out the menu, I immediately spotted a two-item section called Our Focaccia. The round focaccia robiola ($20) had a thin crust that was bumpy, browned, perforated, and unleavened — unlike the usual pizza crust, which is made with either yeast-risen dough or sourdough. This lack of leavening rendered the focaccia engagingly crunchy. It had been split longitudinally while still warm and smeared with robiola, a soft cheese popular in the Piedmont region that may be made with any combination of cow, sheep, and goat milk. Once spread on the crust, it oozed out the side and from the holes on the top.

A hand holds a floppy slice of focaccia with white cheese oozing on the top and sides.

Coco Pazzeria’s focaccia robiola

Eaten warm, the pie was heavenly. A few drops of truffle oil had been added, contributing a subtle and welcome taste to the creaminess of the cheese — though I’m usually suspicious of truffle oil, especially when used ham-fistedly, which is not the case here. I wolfed down the pie, or most of it, sitting on the former loading dock in front of the restaurant in the sunshine, and a week later returned to try the other focaccia ($24), which was set up with the same cheese, to which arugula and thin slices of prosciutto had been added. Damn good, but not quite as good, reading more like a sandwich than a pizza.

Pazzeria’s style of focaccia was almost new to me. I’d had a similar cheese-oozing flatbread at Farina Focaccia & Cucina Italiana in San Francisco’s Mission District a decade earlier, and it had left a similar impression. In the interim, I’d become acquainted with the stuffed pizzas of Abruzzo, a region directly east of Rome across the Apennine Mountains. Those pizzas pressed potatoes, sausage, and cheese between two crusts — at least the version sold at La Villa Pizzeria in Park Slope did. I’ve seen it at other pizzerias around town, too, though research suggests focaccia are more common in that part of Italy than stuffed pizza.

But that was a leavened crust and this was not. And this pie, called a focaccia and not a pizza, was much thinner, flying in the face of the principle that focaccias are commonly defined by being thicker, doughier, and more sparsely topped than pizzas, and often cheeseless. I showed Coco Pazzeria’s robiola pie to focaccia master Rick Easton of Bread & Salt in Jersey City. He immediately identified it as being in the style of focaccia di Recco — referring to a town near Genoa, in Liguria — “but with a different cheese,” he told me.

Two wedges of pizza with very well browned crust dotted with cherry tomatoes

Easton’s focaccia Barese

The cheese in the original version of focaccia di Recco would be stracchino, and the dish was rumored to have been invented by townspeople on the lam in the mountains from the invading Saracens during the Third Crusade in the 1100s. Stracchino, said to be made from the milk of tired cows, is slightly less loamy and funky than robiola, and less prone to clumpy melting. Indeed, it was that meltability, along with a fantastic, cracker-like crust, that made Coco Pazzeria’s focaccia so appealing.

I went on to ask Easton the difference between pizza and focaccia, feeling like he must have a short answer that would clarify the issue for good. I was wrong on that point, because his response was scholarly and complex, but left lots of wiggle room. It’s worth…

Read More: NYC’s Newest Pizza Hits Include Cheesy Focaccia and Buzzetti