Kevin Stefanski defends fourth-down decision with Jacoby Brissett
There was a chance for the Browns to grab an early lead during Sunday’s loss in Cincinnati. However, they threw it away, literally, with a fourth-down incompletion into the end zone.
The Browns, with Deshaun Watson making his second start at quarterback, marched to the Bengals 25. There, after Kareem Hunt was dropped for no gain on third-and-1, coach Kevin Stefanski elected to go for it on fourth down.
However, instead of running something with Watson at quarterback, Stefanski sent Jacoby Brissett in for the play. Brissett was successful converting third- or fourth-and-short situations multiple times during his 11 games as the starter, and even for one play in the previous week’s game at Houston.
Brissett, though, didn’t try a quarterback sneak. Instead, he rolled out and tried to throw to the end zone. The pass, intended for Donovan Peoples-Jones, fell harmlessly on the back line of the end zone, well past the receiver.
Stefanski defended the play in the immediate aftermath. On Monday, on a Zoom call with the media, he said Brissett’s threat to sneak was central to the thinking toward making a quarterback change on the play.
“Yeah, I mean that’s the basis of it,” Stefanski said. “There’s things that we can do that he’s been good at in short yardage that we feel like that gives us an advantage. Obviously, frustrated in the result there and always looking at what we can do better, what I can do better, but that is obviously the idea behind it.”
That was one of six fourth-down tries the Browns had during their 23-10 loss to the Bengals. They converted three, two of which came on a fourth-quarter drive that ended in another failed fourth-down pass to Peoples-Jones − this one by Watson − into the end zone on fourth-and-goal from the Cincinnati 6.
Both the number of fourth-down conversion tries and the number of successful conversions against the Bengals were season highs for the Browns, who lead the league in fourth-down tries with 33 and are second to the Philadelphia Eagles (19) in successful conversions with 18. They also converted three fourth-downs in a Week 3 win over the Pittsburgh Steelers and a Week 6 loss to the New England Patriots, while their previous high in attempts was five.
“I think for me, it’s just trying to put our guys in position to make a play, stay on the field, convert potential threes into sevens,” Stefanski said. “It’s a philosophy that I believe in. We’re going to try to be aggressive, and I think our players understand that we’re trying to be smart while being aggressive.”
The question, though, goes to whether that aggressiveness can backfire on a coach and team. The counter to the decision to go for it on their opening drive in Cincinnati is that the Browns ended up with no points, similar to what happened to them on a failed fourth-down try on their opening drive in Week 4 at Atlanta.
That decision to go for it instead of kicking a very short field goal against the Falcons came back to bite the Browns in a 23-20 loss. It’s hard to say what may have happened Sunday had Brissett or Watson just kept the ball and picked up short yardage needed, or sent Cade York out to kick what would’ve been a 41-yard field goal.
Stefanski, though, isn’t going to change a belief he’s brought with him ever since he was hired as the Browns’ head coach in 2020.
“I think you can look at it in either way,” Stefanski said when asked if a failed fourth-down try is essentially a turnover. “I think it’s a fair question. What you’re also looking at is opportunities for points in those situations.”