Stanford soccer star’s death renews questions about pressures on
That pressure would not have been unique to Meyer, whose death in early March shocked the sports world, said experts who work with student-athletes — none directly with Meyer — to help them overcome mental health challenges.
“Collegiate athletes are just as susceptible, if not more so, to most mental health disorders,” Dr. Claudia Reardon, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Wisconsin, told CNN in an email. “This surprises some people, who see these tough, physically flawless humans and wonder how they could be depressed, anxious, or suicidal.”
Student-athletes live with the same demands as regular college students, like maintaining their grades and social lives and staying connected with their families. But they also face pressure to perform on the field or on the court, demanding practice and workout schedules, traveling and — for those with high profiles — scrutiny from the public and fans on social and in traditional media.
On top of all of that, a stigma persists in the sports world around mental health — discussing it, seeking treatment and, perhaps in doing so, revealing what could be perceived as a weakness, the experts said.
At the same time, participating in sports has huge benefits for many student-athletes’ well-being, they noted, and also can help them cope with mental health problems. And university-level programs increasingly have made it a priority to hire psychologists and others attuned to athletes’ mindset to support students who also came to college for sports.
Still, the pressures student-athletes struggle with are distinct from their non-athlete peers, experts told CNN, while presenting distinct challenges for doctors and others who work with them to overcome mental hurdles.
Demands on student-athletes create particular challenges
Of course, athletes are people, too, and as with any segment of the population, some struggle with mental health. But complicating student-athletes’ mental health challenges are the demands on them and their bodies — and it’s not only anxiety or depression.
For one, student-athletes’ injuries present a risk of post-traumatic stress, said Dr. Josh Norman, an attending psychiatrist at Ohio State University’s Jameson Crane Sports Medicine Institute. After an injury, student-athletes might display hypervigilance, an “aversion” to certain movements or situations that might remind them of the “traumatic event” — all symptoms that can emerge as they work through physical therapy, he said.
“These things can also present in athletics when folks are exposed to a very severe injury or witness a life-threatening (injury) or death of a teammate in extreme sports, for example,” he said.
A student-athlete’s struggles with mental health can also have consequences for their physical health, Norman said.
For instance, anxiety disorders can increase student-athletes’ muscle tension or their tendency to be distracted, impact their sleep and performance, as well as increase the risk of physical injury, Norman said. And when prescribing medicine, he said, student-athletes and doctors have to keep in mind how the drugs might affect athletic performance and whether they might be monitored or banned by the NCAA or anti-doping agencies.
Demands on student-athletes’ time and the expectations they face often mean there’s not much chance of a break, said Chris Bader, the assistant athletic director for mental health and performance at the University of Arkansas. Whereas college students might be able to take a mental health day and skip class, athletes can’t do that.
Attention from the news media and fans can present another risk for student-athletes’ mental health — a sentiment also expressed by professional athletes like Osaka.
Osaka added that while journalists had been kind to her, “I am not a natural public speaker and get huge waves of anxiety before I speak to the world’s media.
College athletes can feel that, too. Many are on a national stage, and Norman hears about bullying when a student-athlete loses a game or makes a mistake, he said. Being in the limelight also can complicate student-athletes’ symptoms of depression and anxiety, as well as their ability to seek treatment privately — like most people can — he said.
Read More: Stanford soccer star’s death renews questions about pressures on